Back to blog

mTechNL Blog

Do You Still Need a Traditional Bank?

Rethinking Banking in the Fintech Era

For a long time, choosing a bank wasn't much of a choice.

You opened an account with one of the familiar institutions - often because it was where your parents banked, there was a branch nearby, or it was simply the bank you'd always used. Your pay went in, your bills came out, and you probably didn't spend much time wondering whether every financial product you used actually needed to come from the same company.

I certainly didn't always think about banking that way.

Today, my financial life looks quite different.

I still actively use RBC. I also use Wealthsimple and Neo Financial, and I've previously used Simplii Financial.

That experience has changed the way I think about banking.

I haven't abandoned traditional banking, nor do I think everyone should. Instead, I've stopped thinking that I need to choose a single financial institution at all.

I don't necessarily need one primary bank. I need financial services - and I can choose the provider that makes the most sense for each one.

That's a relatively simple idea, but fintech has made it much more practical.

Banking is incredibly habitual

There's a reason many of us remain with the same financial institution for years or even decades.

Banking is personal, familiar and inconvenient to change.

Moving your paycheque, automatic payments, savings and other financial activity feels considerably more consequential than switching grocery stores or trying a different phone company. There's also reassurance in knowing that your bank has a branch nearby and that you've dealt with the institution for years.

That familiarity has real value.

But familiarity isn't necessarily the same thing as getting the best product.

The growth of digital banking and financial technology has made it worth periodically asking:

If I were building my financial setup from scratch today, would I choose exactly what I have now?

For some people, the answer will absolutely be yes.

For others, it might be surprisingly different.

My first experience looking beyond traditional banking

My move toward digital financial services didn't happen all at once.

One of the alternatives I previously used was Simplii Financial. I originally opened an account in part because of a promotional interest rate being offered to new clients.

There was nothing particularly terrible about my experience with Simplii.

Over time, though, I found that Wealthsimple and Neo Financial provided a better overall experience for the way I wanted to manage my money.

One of the biggest differences was surprisingly simple: the apps.

I didn't find Simplii's banking app as modern or as user-friendly as the experiences I later found with Wealthsimple and Neo.

With a traditional bank, an app is one of several ways you might interact with the institution.

With a digital financial service, the app effectively becomes the branch.

That makes user experience more than a cosmetic consideration. When your phone is where you check balances, move money, manage cards, save, invest and interact with your financial products, the quality of that interface becomes part of the quality of the financial service itself.

My experience with Simplii also reinforced something else: opening a financial account doesn't mean I need to use it forever.

The promotional rate gave me a reason to try the product. When that reason disappeared and I found alternatives I preferred, I moved on.

What fintech gets right

There are several reasons I've increasingly incorporated fintech into my finances.

Cost is an obvious one.

Depending on the product, digital-first providers can offer no monthly account fees, competitive savings rates, rewards and other benefits without some of the conditions associated with traditional banking packages.

Interest on savings is particularly important to me.

I currently use Neo Financial in part because of its savings offering. I've found its interest offering considerably more attractive than the standard rates I've encountered from many conventional savings products.

That difference matters.

Money sitting in a savings account can look exactly the same regardless of what it's earning. If you aren't periodically comparing rates, it's easy to leave money somewhere simply because that's where it has always been.

I've also enjoyed Neo's rewards and referral ecosystem. Those aren't reasons by themselves to choose a financial institution, but when I already like the underlying product, they're meaningful additions.

Then there's Wealthsimple.

Why I use Wealthsimple

What I particularly like about Wealthsimple is the breadth of its ecosystem.

It brings everyday financial services, saving and investing together in a modern interface. Its trading experience is convenient and approachable, and having those products within the same environment makes managing different parts of my finances feel much more cohesive.

I also appreciate its USD account offering, which gives me a convenient way to hold U.S. dollars and earn interest without the kind of monthly account fee I might otherwise associate with a specialized account.

Wealthsimple has also been adding services that increasingly blur the distinction between fintech and traditional banking.

Services such as mobile cheque deposits, physical cheques, bank drafts, bill payments and Interac e-Transfers are no longer necessarily exclusive to the conventional branch-banking model.

Even physical cash - something that seems like an obvious weakness of a digital financial platform - now has another solution.

Wealthsimple supports cash deposits through participating Canada Post locations. Here in Mount Pearl, I've personally used Canada Post at Shoppers Drug Mart to deposit cash into my Wealthsimple account.

That's not something I would have associated with a digital financial platform a few years ago.

So why do I still use RBC?

Because traditional banking still does things that are useful to me.

And I don't see any reason to give those things up merely so I can say I've completely switched to fintech.

Cash is a perfect example.

One way I handle physical cash is:

Cash -> RBC account -> Interac e-Transfer -> Wealthsimple or Neo

I can deposit cash through RBC and then move it electronically to whichever platform I actually want the money in.

Alternatively, when it's more convenient:

Cash -> Canada Post -> Wealthsimple

The fact that I have both options is valuable.

RBC's physical infrastructure can solve a problem for me when I need it. Wealthsimple and Neo can provide products I prefer for other purposes.

Why should I force myself to choose?

Maybe "switching banks" is the wrong idea

This is probably the biggest conclusion I've reached through using RBC, Simplii, Wealthsimple and Neo.

We tend to talk about financial institutions as if we're choosing teams.

Which bank are you with?

It's such a normal question that we rarely think about the assumption contained within it - that one institution should sit at the centre of our entire financial life.

I'm increasingly unconvinced that it has to.

I can use a traditional bank where its physical infrastructure makes my life easier.

I can use Neo where its savings products make sense for my money.

I can use Wealthsimple for investing and the growing collection of everyday financial services I prefer there.

And if another product becomes more competitive in the future, I can evaluate that too.

Instead of asking:

"Which bank am I with?"

I've started asking:

"Which financial product makes the most sense for what I'm trying to do?"

That's a subtle distinction, but it's changed the way I manage my money.

Fintech isn't traditional banking without the disadvantages

None of this means fintech is automatically better.

Digital-first banking comes with compromises, and I think anyone discussing its benefits should be willing to talk about them.

Physical branches still matter.

If something unusual goes wrong, there can be considerable value in walking into a branch and speaking with another person face-to-face. Some people simply prefer dealing with a human being when their money is involved.

Cash can still be less straightforward. Canada Post deposits and transfers from another institution give me workable solutions, but they're still different from having access to a conventional branch network.

Traditional institutions can also offer enormous ranges of products and services under one roof. Depending on your needs, lending, mortgages, foreign currency, specialized transactions, financial advice and other services may be easier to handle through an established bank or credit union.

Digital platforms also inherently create greater dependence on technology.

If your financial relationship primarily exists through an app, service interruptions, account-access problems, lost devices and remote customer support can become much more significant.

Those aren't arguments against fintech.

They're part of deciding whether a particular product actually fits your life.

And what about safety?

This is one area where I don't think anyone should make assumptions.

A financial app looking and behaving like a bank doesn't necessarily mean the company behind it is structured like a traditional Canadian bank.

Different financial products can hold customer funds in different ways, and applicable deposit protection can depend on the institution, account and underlying arrangement.

Before putting substantial savings anywhere, I think it's important to understand a few things:

Who actually holds the money?
What deposit protection applies?
What are the applicable limits?
Does that protection apply to the particular product I'm using?

Those questions aren't arguments against fintech.

They're part of being an informed customer.

The best setup may be a hybrid

The more fintech I've used, the less interested I've become in the idea of completely abandoning traditional banking.

That's because I don't think abandoning it should be the goal.

Getting more value from my financial setup is the goal.

For me, that currently means a hybrid approach.

RBC remains part of my financial environment.

Neo serves purposes I particularly like it for.

Wealthsimple serves others.

Simplii served a purpose for me previously, and when I no longer found it as compelling as the alternatives, I stopped using it.

None of these decisions need to be permanent.

That's perhaps one of the biggest advantages consumers have gained from the growth of fintech: competition and choice.

Habit has a cost

There's nothing inherently wrong with banking at the same institution for 10, 20 or 40 years.

If the products are competitive, the service works for you and you're receiving value from the relationship, staying can be an entirely rational decision.

But I think it's worth distinguishing between:

"This is where I've always banked."
and
"This is currently the best financial setup for me."

Those are not necessarily the same statement.

Look at the monthly fees you're paying.

Look at the interest you're earning.

Look at the services you actually use.

Consider how often you visit a branch - and the circumstances where you'd be glad to have one.

Then look at the alternatives available today.

And don't just compare institutions. Compare individual products.

You may conclude that your traditional bank is still exactly where you want to be.

You may discover that a fintech alternative works better.

Or you might reach the same conclusion I did:

You don't actually have to choose.

Building my own financial ecosystem

Technology hasn't convinced me that traditional banks are obsolete.

It has convinced me that the idea of choosing one institution and automatically giving it every part of my financial life is becoming outdated.

My setup today is something I've assembled.

Traditional banking infrastructure when I need it.

Digital-first banking where I prefer it.

Better savings opportunities where they're available.

Investing tools where they're convenient.

And the freedom to reconsider any of those decisions when the products change.

That's ultimately what I find exciting about the shift toward fintech.

It isn't necessarily about replacing banks.

It's about having enough competition, technology and choice that we can build a financial environment around our own needs instead of simply accepting the one we've always had.

Want to explore the platforms I use?

I currently use both Wealthsimple and Neo Financial. My experience with them is part of what prompted me to write this article in the first place.

If you've read about them, done your own comparison and decide that either one makes sense for you, I've included my personal referral links below.

Wealthsimple

My referral link:

wealthsimple.com/invite/C4SGMZ

Neo Financial

My referral link:

neo.cc/refer/V2N5K6R7&utm_source=referral&utm_channel=customer

A note about these links

These are my personal referral links. If you use one to sign up and satisfy the applicable promotional requirements, I may receive a referral benefit. Depending on the promotion in effect at the time, you may also be eligible for a reward or other benefit.

Referral offers, interest rates, account features and eligibility requirements can change, so check the provider's current information and terms before signing up.

And I wouldn't recommend opening a financial account solely because there's a referral bonus - including through one of my links.

Look at the underlying product. Compare it with what you already have. Understand its fees and limitations, how your money is held, and what deposit protection applies.

If the product genuinely provides something better for you, consider it.

If it doesn't, keep what works.

That's really the point.

This article reflects my personal experience and is provided for general informational purposes. It isn't individualized financial advice.